Super Bowl Prop Betting

Go straight to the content.

The Super Bowl attracts a significant amount of prop betting, surpassing any other sporting event. Almost every aspect of the NFL’s grandest game is subject to betting, and in New York, you can find online sportsbooks offering wagers on all of it. This comprehensive guide highlights the various prop bets available at legal online betting sites in NY for the Super Bowl.

Live Super Bowl Prop Odds

The current Super Bowl prop odds are available at legal online sportsbooks. You can search for any team or player to find specific odds. However, please note that due to NY legislation, not all individual props may be available for betting during the Super Bowl. Click on the odds to be redirected to the sportsbook and learn more.

Best Super Bowl prop betting sites

Rank
Sportsbooks
Bonus
Feature
Play
1
125% WELCOME BONUS
Up to $1250 to bet on sports
250% Slots + Table Bonus
150 Free Spins On Gorilla Or Buffalo Ways
50 Daily Boost For Your Massive Wins
Grab your 175% + 50 free spins
3
$1,000
No Sweat First Bet
Up to $1,000 No Sweat First Bet
Available on Desktop, Android & iOS  
To Claim: Click Play Now
4
In Bonus Bets
UP TO $1,000
Free Live Streaming - Watch Live Games
$1,000 Paid Back in Bonus Bets
Use Bonus Code: PLAYBONUS
  • DraftKings in New York is the top choice for a comprehensive display of Super Bowl prop options and a user-friendly live prop betting platform.
  • FanDuel in New York excels in offering the most competitive Super Bowl prop lines.
  • If you’re looking for a wide range of Super Bowl bets, especially props, BetMGM New York is your top choice.
  • A winning combination in New York: PointsBet offers PointsBetting and Super Bowl props.
  • BetRivers in New York is the ideal choice for those seeking a loyalty program that offers rewards specifically for Super Bowl prop betting.

How to bet on Super Bowl props in NY

To participate in legal online sports betting in New York, it is essential to have an account with a licensed online sportsbook. Here’s a simple guide on obtaining one:

  1. Select a sportsbook of your preference and proceed to visit its website.
  2. Sign up and avail various sportsbook promotions and bonus codes.
  3. Make sure to visit the Super Bowl page of the sportsbook to find any prop bets that interest you and that you may want to place.
  4. Choose your selections, complete a betting slip, and verify your wagers.

During the game, you can find most props and bet on them at live Super Bowl prop odds. However, it is important to use licensed betting sites that operate in New York to ensure consumer protection. Offshore sportsbooks may provide a wider range of Super Bowl props, including exotic ones, but they lack the necessary safeguards. If any issues arise and your money goes missing, you would likely have no recourse.

NY vs. NJ Super Bowl props

Before New York legalized online sports betting, New Jersey had already emerged as the top destination for New Yorkers seeking to place bets on the Super Bowl. If you resided nearby, you had the convenience of easily crossing state borders to engage in betting activities. Additionally, it was even possible to place online wagers from as close as a PATH subway platform situated in New Jersey.

By February 2024, New Yorkers should no longer have to travel to place bets on Super Bowl props. The New York State Gaming Commission has recently suggested granting licenses to nine online sportsbooks to operate within the state, with the final decision expected in November 2021.

The majority of people should be settled in their new homes by February 2024. Additionally, it is expected that the NYS Gaming Commission will have a similar stance on Super Bowl proposition bets as the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement. Sportsbooks will need to obtain regulatory approval in order to offer prop bets for the Super Bowl. If regulators in New York are as accommodating as those in New Jersey, residents of New York should have the opportunity to place bets on numerous prop options within the state for Super Bowl LVI.

What are the top Super Bowl prop bets?

During the Super Bowl, the majority of prop bets will center around the actual gameplay. There will be a wide range of options available for betting on individual and team achievements, such as:

  • What will be the first score: touchdown, field goal, or safety?
  • Who will be the first player to score a touchdown?
  • Which quarterback will accumulate a greater number of passing yards?
  • Is a defensive touchdown expected to occur?
  • Is there going to be a safety?
  • Who will be the recipient of the Super Bowl MVP award?
  • Betting on the total number of touchdowns, rushing yards, passing yards, or receiving yards for any player.
  • Place your bets on the total number of touchdowns, rushing yards, passing yards, and receiving yards for either team, whether it’s over or under.
  • Total combined TDs.

Furthermore, it is possible that you could place certain props at regulated mobile betting apps in NY. However, if you cannot find them there, they might be accessible at books in New Jersey.

  • Is it possible for a scoring drive to be shorter than the national anthem?
  • Heads or tails, the coin toss?
  • Which color of Gatorade will be poured on the coach of the victorious team?

Super Bowl crossover props

While the Super Bowl may be the most prominent event, it is not the sole attraction in town. In February, the NBA and NHL seasons are in full swing, often hosting games on Super Bowl Sunday or the surrounding days. This scheduling overlap leads to crossover betting opportunities, including props that incorporate NBA or NHL events alongside the Super Bowl.

For example, you may have the opportunity to place a bet on whether LeBron James’ point total will exceed Derrick Henry’s rushing attempts. Alternatively, you could bet on whether the total number of punts by both Super Bowl teams will surpass James Harden’s rebound count.

Exotic Super Bowl prop bets

In the Super Bowl props market, you can typically find some unique bets. These can range from loosely connected aspects of the game to rare on-field occurrences. These bets are often referred to as exotics.

Keep in mind, in case the New York State Gaming Commission restricts licensed sportsbooks from offering certain props, the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement may allow it. This implies that you can simply cross the state border to place your bets on those props.

  • Is it possible for a TD to be overturned by replay?
  • What is the total count of players attempting a pass?
  • Which color of Gatorade will the victorious team pour over their coach?
  • A touchdown can be scored by any player in the offensive or defensive line.

Super Bowl prop bet sheet

Nevertheless, it is important to note that online sportsbooks in New York and New Jersey will not have the ability to provide certain extravagant prop bets that you may have come across. In the event that you come across any of these types of bets, it is probable that you are dealing with an offshore sportsbook, which entails potential risks, as mentioned earlier.

  • Who will be the first person that the Super Bowl MVP expresses gratitude to?
  • Which beer brand is set to air the inaugural beer commercial?
  • During the game, will the price of Bitcoin increase, decrease, or remain unchanged?
  • Is it possible for there to be a streaker?
  • Is there a possibility that a player will ask his girlfriend to marry him on the field following the game?

Super Bowl party betting sheets — prop betting at home

In order to engage all your guests at your Super Bowl party this year, consider arranging a home prop game. Just create a sheet featuring your preferred prop bets and distribute it to everyone.

Make sure to include the wildest options you can come across. Distribute the sheets to your guests upon their arrival, ensuring that they complete it before the very first item on the list is resolved. Evaluate the completed sheets, assigning scores and presenting prizes for specific items and the highest number of accurate responses.